HomeNewsAnalysisHow Mexico's Journalists Are Failed by the Government
ANALYSIS

How Mexico's Journalists Are Failed by the Government

MEXICO / 25 MAY 2012 BY PATRICK CORCORAN EN

Mexico has suffered a rash of deadly attacks against journalists, made worse by a report suggesting that some of those killed may have been named on a hit list seen by the government, which did little to protect them.

Six Mexican reporters have been killed in recent weeks, with four deaths in Veracruz, the Gulf state that has seen one of the biggest spikes in violence in recent months. A reporter for Proceso magazine was killed in Xalapa on April 28, days before three photojournalists were found murdered in Boca del Rio, along with the girlfriend of one of the victims. A former reporter, who had left the business several months previously, was murdered in the central state of Morelos, and another was found dead in Sonora, which borders on the US.

The events are even more troubling in light of a report by Proceso, which stated that the federal and state governments were aware of a hit list circulating in Veracruz last year with the names of journalists to be targeted by criminal groups, which may have included the four who were murdered. (The administration of Veracruz Governor Javier Duarte denies knowing of any such list, according to the magazine.) Proceso reported that the Calderon administration only passed the warning on to TV giant Televisa, which moved its correspondent out of the state.

The recent killings continue an alarming trend in Mexico, which is among the most dangerous countries in the world for journalists. According to the National Human Rights Commission, 81 journalists have been murdered in Mexico since 2000. Most of these deaths took place during the Calderon presidency, accompanying an nationwide explosion of violence linked to organized crime. In addition to the killings, threats are common, and criminal groups have frequently trained their weapons on the media as a way to send a message.

Criminal groups target reporters for a number of reasons. Often, it is simply retribution for publishing information about government investigations or official corruption which damages their business. Because attacks on journalists receive so much publicity, they have a chilling effect on the population at large, discouraging citizens from reporting criminal activity. Some reporters may also be attacked because they receive money from criminal groups, making them a target for rivals.

This recent spate of killings has provoked renewed calls for a more robust government response to the attacks. One suggestion is to make all killings of journalists into federal cases, which means they would be dealt with by investigative teams considered to be more competent than the state officials, who deal with most murders. Moreover, as Ivan Baez of Article 19 pointed out, because state-level officials are often suspected of involvement in crimes against journalists, tasking them with investigating these crimes could stand in the way of justice.

More recently, various politicians have called upon Calderon to enact a law to protect rights activists and journalists that was passed by both houses of Congress earlier this year, and is currently stuck in limbo. There seems to be little good reason for Calderon’s inaction. The law would offer threatened activists and journalists police protection and bodyguards, armored cars, bullet-proof vests, and temporary relocation.

However, it’s also worth noting that the absence of robust legislation is not the biggest problem here. The government created a special prosecutor for crimes against journalists under President Vicente Fox, but the office is widely viewed as ineffectual if not useless, and attacks on reporters have only grown more frequent since its creation.

More troubling than Calderon’s failure to enact the law is what it represents: a lack of genuine interest in protecting journalists, evident across the country at every level of government. (However, journalists are not alone in this: the fact that roughly 80 percent of all murders go unsolved demonstrates a lack of interest in justice for victims, of whatever profession.) As the failure of the special prosecutor demonstrates, merely adding new agencies into the mix is unlikely to change anything.

Moreover, while the plan to give investigators an added push and extra resources to track down those who attack journalists is laudable, it’s worth noting that the authorities already have all of the legal tools they need to do this. Anyone convicted of murder faces a lengthy prison sentence in Mexico. If the local authorities made a point of concentrating their resources disproportionately on those who attack reporters, making the conviction rate in such case higher, than criminal groups facing a journalistic nuisance might think twice before resorting to violence.

That is, after all, the biggest reason that attacks on journalists, even when they publish damning information about criminal operations, are so rare in more developed countries: such crimes place a great deal of pressure on the government to solve them, which, in turn, makes a conviction more likely still. In short, it’s not in criminals’ interest to target reporters.

For anyone interested in the integrity of journalism in Mexico and around Latin America, that reorganization of the prevailing incentives needs to be the goal. As analysts from organizations ranging from Amnesty International to Article 19 have pointed out, new legislation can help achieve that objective, but it will not be enough on its own.

Image, above, shows protests over the death of Proceso reporter Regina Martinez.

share icon icon icon

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

What are your thoughts? Click here to send InSight Crime your comments.

We encourage readers to copy and distribute our work for non-commercial purposes, with attribution to InSight Crime in the byline and links to the original at both the top and bottom of the article. Check the Creative Commons website for more details of how to share our work, and please send us an email if you use an article.

Tags

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

Related Content

MEXICO / 11 OCT 2013

As Nicaragua prepares to extradite 18 Mexican citizens convicted of drug trafficking while posing as journalists, questions linger regarding the…

HUMAN TRAFFICKING / 12 SEP 2011

A Mexican judge handed out lengthy prison sentences to a couple at the head of a human trafficking network that…

HUMAN RIGHTS / 1 OCT 2015

A new report from Mexico’s National Commission on Human Rights documents the deplorable conditions in the nation's prisons, highlighting a…

About InSight Crime

THE ORGANIZATION

Venezuela’s Tren de Aragua Becomes Truly Transnational

29 JUL 2022

This week, InSight Crime published a deep dive into the total control that Venezuelan mega-gang, Tren de Aragua, has over the lives of those it smuggles between Venezuela and Chile…

THE ORGANIZATION

Turkish Traffickers Delivering Latin American Cocaine to Persian Gulf

15 JUL 2022

Last week, InSight Crime published the second half of an investigation piecing together the emerging role of Turkish cocaine traffickers in supplying Russia and the Persian Gulf, which are among…

THE ORGANIZATION

Turkey as a Lynchpin in European Cocaine Pipeline

8 JUL 2022

InSight Crime is extending its investigation into the cocaine pipeline to Europe, and tracking the growing connections between Latin American drug traffickers and European criminal organizations. This led us to…

THE ORGANIZATION

Memo Fantasma Coverage Gets Worldwide Attention

1 JUL 2022

Guillermo Acevedo, the former Colombian drug lord and paramilitary commander better known as Memo Fantasma, may soon be allowed to leave prison. Since first revealing the identity of Memo Fantasma…

THE ORGANIZATION

Who Are Memo Fantasma and Sergio Roberto de Carvalho?

24 JUN 2022

Inside the criminal career of Memo Fantasma  In March 2020, InSight Crime revealed the identity and whereabouts of Memo Fantasma, a paramilitary commander and drug trafficker living in…