HomeNewsAnalysisWhy Is Mexico Rejecting UN Findings on Disappearances?
ANALYSIS

Why Is Mexico Rejecting UN Findings on Disappearances?

HUMAN RIGHTS / 18 FEB 2015 BY KYRA GURNEY EN

Mexico has refuted the findings of a United Nations committee on the country's enforced disappearances while welcoming input from a regional human rights body, raising questions about why the government is trying to discredit the committee's conclusions.

The Mexican government has questioned the UN Committee on Enforced Disappearances' (CED) report stating that disappearances are a widespread problem, and that enforced disappearances -- which are technically disappearances that involve security forces or other state officials -- have been met with almost total impunity, reported Milenio.

In the CED's report (pdf), which was concluded on February 11, the committee expressed its "concern over impunity in numerous cases of enforced disappearances, as evidenced by the almost complete lack of convictions for this crime."

The CED recommended that the Mexican government take a series of actions to address this problem, including creating a special prosecution unit in the Attorney General's Office, investigating officials and state agencies, and protecting individuals who report the crime. The CED also pushed for the Mexican government to recognize its competency to review individual cases.

In response, the Mexican government issued a press release stating that the committee's findings do not "adequately reflect the information presented or provide additional elements to reinforce the actions and commitments that have been undertaken to address the challenges mentioned," reported Eje Central.

In addition, Mexican Foreign Minister Jose Antonio Meade told La Jornada that there were inaccuracies in the CED's recommendations "which make us think the review wasn't as exhaustive as it should have been."

Meanwhile, Meade recently stated that the government would welcome the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights' (IACHR) input on the case involving 43 students who disappeared in Guerrero state last September.

InSight Crime Analysis

The Mexican government has a number of possible motives for rejecting the CED's findings and recommendations. For one, the CED's conclusions cast the Mexican government in an unfavorable light and undermine President Enrique Peña Nieto's campaign to improve the country's international image.

"The report is very critical of the Mexican government's handling of disappearances and enforced disappearances in the country at a time when the government is feeling already in the spotlight about this issue because of the 43 students who were enforced disappeared in September," Maureen Meyer, a Senior Associate for Mexico and Migrant Rights at the Washington Office on Latin America (WOLA), told InSight Crime. "I think they're feeling very much on the defensive right now."

Another point of contention is the CED's allegations that enforced disappearances are a widespread problem in Mexico, while the Mexican government maintains that many of the country's disappearances likely have other explanations. Jesus Perez, an independent investigator and expert on organized crime in Mexico, told InSight Crime that Mexico has likely rejected the CED's request to review individual cases because it could "shed 'too much' light on issues like the role of military forces in the disappearances of individuals supposedly linked to drug trafficking."

SEE ALSO: Mexico News and Profiles

On the other hand, although the IACHR can make recommendations about the government's general approach to disappearances, their investigation is focused mainly on the case of the 43 students (pdf). As Meyer told InSight Crime, the Mexican government has agreed to their involvement in this specific investigation at the request of the victims' families and human rights organizations.

The Mexican government may also wish to be seen as cooperative without wanting to actually air its dirty laundry in public. "The Mexican government has on several occasions on the one hand welcomed international scrutiny on their human rights situation and then when reports come out from rapporteurs or in this case a committee, kind of backtracked and worked to discredit the work," Meyer said. 

share icon icon icon

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

What are your thoughts? Click here to send InSight Crime your comments.

We encourage readers to copy and distribute our work for non-commercial purposes, with attribution to InSight Crime in the byline and links to the original at both the top and bottom of the article. Check the Creative Commons website for more details of how to share our work, and please send us an email if you use an article.

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

Related Content

ELITES AND CRIME / 21 MAR 2018

Mexico continues to be one of the most dangerous places in the world for journalists, according to a new report…

INFOGRAPHICS / 16 DEC 2012

Just days after the fire at the Casino Royale, authorities captured five suspects, one of whom was a state policeman.

MEXICO / 14 JUN 2011

Police thwarted the attempted lynching of four suspected thieves in Mexico City, on the same day that the government launched…

About InSight Crime

THE ORGANIZATION

Who Are Memo Fantasma and Sergio Roberto de Carvalho?

24 JUN 2022

Inside the criminal career of Memo Fantasma  In March 2020, InSight Crime revealed the identity and whereabouts of Memo Fantasma, a paramilitary commander and drug trafficker living in…

THE ORGANIZATION

Environmental and Academic Praise

17 JUN 2022

InSight Crime’s six-part series on the plunder of the Peruvian Amazon continues to inform the debate on environmental security in the region. Our Environmental Crimes Project Manager, María Fernanda Ramírez,…

LA ORGANIZACIÓN

Series on Plunder of Peru’s Amazon Makes Headlines

10 JUN 2022

Since launching on June 2, InSight Crime’s six-part series on environmental crime in Peru’s Amazon has been well-received. Detailing the shocking impunity enjoyed by those plundering the rainforest, the investigation…

THE ORGANIZATION

Duarte’s Death Makes Waves

3 JUN 2022

The announcement of the death of Gentil Duarte, one of the top dissident commanders of the defunct Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC), continues to reverberate in Venezuela and Colombia.

THE ORGANIZATION

Cattle Trafficking Acclaim, Investigation into Peru’s Amazon 

27 MAY 2022

On May 18, InSight Crime launched its most recent investigation into cattle trafficking between Central America and Mexico. It showed precisely how beef, illicitly produced in Honduras, Guatemala…