HomeNewsAnalysisHow Brazil’s Presidential Candidates Would Tackle Deepening Insecurity
ANALYSIS

How Brazil's Presidential Candidates Would Tackle Deepening Insecurity

BRAZIL / 30 AUG 2018 BY MIKE LASUSA EN

With crime and violence on the rise across Brazil, security has become a major theme in the run-up to the October presidential election. But do any of the candidates have a solid plan to handle the issue?

The short answer is no. The presidential hopefuls have studiously avoided talking about the country's most potent criminal threat, the First Capital Command (Primeiro Comando da Capital - PCC). And most of their proposals for reducing violence and crime are either vague, infeasible or wrongheaded.

Below, InSight Crime breaks down the security platforms of the three most viable candidates.

The Firebrand: Jair Bolsonaro

Polls have consistently shown that former army paratrooper and current congressman Jair Bolsonaro is one of the top contenders for the presidency, despite his record of making racist, sexist and homophobic remarks, and defending the brutal military dictatorship that ruled Brazil from the 1960s to the 1980s, in part because of what he claims were its successes in fighting crime.

Bolsonaro's published platform advocates for "redirecting the policy of human rights, prioritizing the defense of victims of violence."

In February, Bolsonaro and his son Eduardo, who also serves in Congress, presented a bill that would strengthen protections for members of the security forces accused of unlawful use of force. But as demonstrated in countries like El Salvador, giving virtually free reign to police to kill suspected criminals has a negative, rather than positive impact on security.

The candidate also supports lowering the age at which people can be criminally charged as an adult from 18 to 16, and favors increasing criminal penalties more broadly.

His platform uses the catchphrase, "Prender e deixar preso," which loosely translated means, "Detain them and leave them in prison." However, cramming more people into Brazil's overcrowded penitentiary system will only provide more recruits for the gangs that dominate the prisons.

SEE ALSO: Brazil News and Profiles

In addition, Bolsonaro has long advocated reforming Brazil's gun laws, which place tight restrictions on the private ownership of weapons.

"We have to give the right to own guns to everyone," he told news outlet O Globo earlier this year. "There's already a bang-bang in Brazil, but only one side can shoot."

Contrary to Bolsonaro's claims, there is no credible evidence that increased gun ownership rates improve security. In fact, firearms are used to commit the majority of deadly violence in Latin America. Putting more guns into the hands of citizens is likely to worsen the situation.

Perhaps Bolsonaro's only proposal that could generate positive results is his call to "invest strongly in equipment, technology, intelligence and the investigative capacity of the police." Still, Brazil has been suffering serious economic problems that have hindered the country's ability to "invest strongly" in anything, and it's not clear that prioritizing security over other sectors would be the best use of limited resources.

The Idealists: Lula/Fernando Haddad

The highly popular former President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva is technically the candidate of the Workers' Party (Partido dos Trabalhadores - PT), but he is likely to be kicked out of the race due to a corruption conviction. He is expected to throw his support behind his current running mate, former São Paulo Mayor Fernando Haddad.

The security proposals in the platform published under Lula's name, which Haddad also backs, are essentially the exact opposite of those advocated by Bolsonaro.

The platform urges prioritizing human rights and cautions against militarized security policies. It also advocates for improving controls on firearms.

In addition, the plan suggests decriminalizing drugs and bolstering programs to prevent drug use.

In a recent interview with El País, Haddad criticized the so-called war on drugs.

"We're deluding people that we're fighting something. We're not fighting anything. We're losing the war," he said.

Still, the PT platform does promote continued efforts to address organized crime and the international drug trade, noting that drug trafficking money "fuels various spheres of the economy, provides access to weapons in large numbers that encourage lethal violence, and finances corruption and other criminal activities."

The platform also points to the role that mass incarceration plays in aiding the activities of criminal organizations, and discusses the possibility of implementing alternatives to incarceration.

In addition, the plan advocates a greater degree of integration and coordination among federal, state and local authorities working on security issues. However, it is critical of a law passed earlier this year that set up an information-sharing and coordination system for various law enforcement agencies. The PT pledged to try to modify that legislation and also seek constitutional reforms along those lines.

While these proposals could hold some promise for addressing problems of crime and violence in Brazil, politics will likely prevent them from moving forward.

The once-powerful PT has been weakened by revelations of extensive corruption in the party, and a powerful conservative coalition known as the "beef, bullets and bible caucus" is sure to strongly resist these measures.

Even if a hypothetical PT government could scrape together the political support, the initiatives discussed above would require a large financial investment, which would be complicated by the previously mentioned economic problems.

The Establishment: Geraldo Alckmin

The former governor of the state of São Paulo, Geraldo Alckmin, is supported by a large coalition of centrist parties, but recent polls show voters are less enthused about his candidacy.

This is probably due to the fact that his platform, especially the security plank, consists largely of vague platitudes and policy proposals that appeal mainly to Brazil's established political and economic elites.

One of Alckmin's blandest ideas is "increasing judicial and police cooperation with neighboring countries," a perennial favorite talking point for leaders across the region.

Alckmin also proposes to build more prisons in order to reduce severe overcrowding. However, he simultaneously vows to increase prison terms for minor crimes, which could counteract gains from building more facilities, since more inmates would be staying in the system for longer periods of time.

SEE ALSO: Coverage of Security Policy

There are further contradictions in Alckmin's security plan. For example, he has claimed to be against Bolsonaro's proposal to loosen gun laws.

"The way out isn't to arm the population," he told O Globo in April. "That only increases the general sense of insecurity."

But earlier this month, Alckmin's running mate told Bloomberg that the former São Paulo governor, if elected president, would seek to make it easier for rural workers to obtain firearms.

In addition, Alckmin has said that he wants to improve and standardize police training, including by creating a national police academy to train instructors.

At first glance, this sounds like a reasonable idea. But his preferred law enforcement strategy is slightly schizophrenic.

On one hand, Alckmin has voiced support for a type of "hot spot" policing, which involves targeting law enforcement resources on high-crime areas. This type of policy has proven effective in certain cases in the past.

However, the candidate has also promoted a "broken windows" approach, based on the dubious theory that cracking down on minor crimes will discourage individuals from committing more serious offenses. This strategy has shown little long-term success in Latin America, and has come with plenty of drawbacks, particularly when it comes to human rights.

Perhaps more unsettling is Alckmin's call for a back-door militarization of citizen security efforts via the creation of a "national guard" staffed by ex-soldiers working out of military barracks in coordination with civilian police.

Calling on the military when the security situation takes a downturn has been a popular move in the past -- not just in Brazil, but across Latin America. However, history has shown that the strategy holds little promise for generating sustainable improvements, and in fact, can often exacerbate problems with crime and violence in the long run.

share icon icon icon

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

What are your thoughts? Click here to send InSight Crime your comments.

We encourage readers to copy and distribute our work for non-commercial purposes, with attribution to InSight Crime in the byline and links to the original at both the top and bottom of the article. Check the Creative Commons website for more details of how to share our work, and please send us an email if you use an article.

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

Related Content

BRAZIL / 22 JAN 2015

By one watchdog's count, about 86 percent of the world's most violent cities are based in Latin America, a phenomenon…

BRAZIL / 2 JUL 2014

The discovery of a cyber crime operation in Brazil that may have stolen billions of dollars from Internet users is…

BRAZIL / 23 FEB 2016

Brazilian authorities have arrested a high-profile political strategist and public relations guru, in a case highlighting the difficulties of…

About InSight Crime

THE ORGANIZATION

InSight Crime’s Greater Focus on US-Mexico Border

20 JUL 2021

InSight Crime has decided to turn many of its investigative resources towards understanding and chronicling the criminal dynamics along the US-Mexico border.

THE ORGANIZATION

Key Arrests and Police Budget Increases Due to InSight Crime Investigations

8 JUL 2021

With Memo Fantasma’s arrest, InSight Crime has proven that our investigations can and will uncover major criminal threats in the Americas.

THE ORGANIZATION

Organized Crime’s Influence on Gender-Based Violence

30 JUN 2021

InSight Crime investigator Laura N. Ávila spoke on organized crime and gender-based violence at the launch of a research project by the United Nations Development Programme.

THE ORGANIZATION

Conversation with Paraguay Judicial Operators on PCC

24 JUN 2021

InSight Crime Co-director Steven Dudley formed part of a panel attended by over 500 students, all of whom work in Paraguay's judicial system.

THE ORGANIZATION

Combating Environmental Crime in Colombia

15 JUN 2021

InSight Crime presented findings from an investigation into the main criminal activities fueling environmental destruction in Colombia.