HomeNewsAnalysisHow the US Can Aid Police Reform in Latin America
ANALYSIS

How the US Can Aid Police Reform in Latin America

POLICE REFORM / 7 MAR 2012 BY EDWARD FOX EN

A Center for Strategic and International Studies report looks at how US can help police reform in Latin America, but its analysis of where the needs are greatest may overlook some countries further from the US border.

"Police Reform in Latin America: Implications for US Policy," published by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), approaches the issue of police reform from an outside donor perspective. Noting the inconsistency of US-led initiatives historically, and the need to re-address the issue, the report leads with two questions: "Why spend (US) tax dollars on this?" and "Where are the needs greatest?"

The report cites figures suggesting more than a quarter of Latin Americans have "no confidence" in the police, while 44 percent believe their police force to be involved in crime. Some 31 percent of citizens believe corruption to be the primary problem in the police, while over 22 percent seeing it as being under-staffing.

Despite this prevalence of public mistrust toward police in Latin America, the report notes that no single solution can be proposed for the region. It cites differences relating to countries' societies and institutional capacities, who has control over the police force, and past failings by the US in aiding reform.

The CSIS suggests centralizing US-aided efforts through a single agency to avoid inefficient and "piecemeal implementation." It also says there is a need for international coordination, thanks to the growing number of multilateral agencies involved in the reform agenda.

Among other recommendations propounded by the authors are:

Anticipate that citizen security will continue to surpass traditional defense threats in many Latin American countries, making the need to address societal issues (education, poverty, underemployment) of pressing concern if a fertile environment for police reform measures is to be built.

Prioritize US aid for police reform for countries that demonstrate commitment to the agenda; those with low political will for reform, such as Guatemala, need more diplomatic pressure.

Make Mexico the first investment priority and its Central American neighbors a secondary target.

The CSIS also notes "future challenges" that could arise in Bolivia, Venezuela and Cuba, but says that the political situations in these countries mean US assistance is less practical.

Though the report's recommendations are a useful addition to the debate, the categorizations of countries into those of greater and lesser need, and the resulting framework for prioritization, risk misrepresenting the situation.

For example, Brazil and Colombia are categorized as countries "Where needs are less." On Brazil, the report says the overriding concern is the need to "better train and equip" the police force to face the threat from drug lords and criminal gangs in the country's favelas. While this is valid, it ignores the well documented problem of police-run militias, which have a presence in 11 of Brazil's 27 states, providing bootleg public services and forming death squads.

Brazil has undertaken an ambitious reform program on its own, and is far wealthier than many other countries in the region. It is therefore less in need to US assistance. However, by not mentioning the unique dynamic of police corruption in the country, the report risks misrepresenting the issue. In Colombia, likewise, the CSIS points to an expansion in police numbers as a wholly positive development, without exploring the level of corruption

The categorization of countries "Where needs are greater" for US-aided reform follows the path north toward the US border. Thanks to its proximity to the US, and notoriety internationally as the center of the drug war, Mexico gets special attention. The report gives damning statistics on the number of crimes investigated and sent to court in Mexico, and notes that police receive low wages and can often earn more by collaborating with drug gangs.

While this is valid, the case of Honduras, where the level and nature of corruption is more severe, receives comparatively scant attention.

As InSight Crime has noted, Honduras presents an extreme example of police corruption. Some Honduran officials have not only been corrupted but are themselves instigators of the violence consuming the country. Examples include cases ranging from alleged police involvement in the murder of two university students last year, to prison officials collaborating with inmates, allegedly releasing them on a weekly basis to traffic drugs. Impunity rates are in the 90 percent bracket, according to some reports, not unlike Mexico, yet this receives little mention by the CSIS. A staggering 72 percent of the Honduran public don't feel safe with their police force.

The report does highlight the criminal infiltration of the Honduran police, pointing to reports of officers working as "air traffic controllers" for drug flights. In Honduras, the CSIS rightly says that reform of police and justice institutions should be prioritized over the need to train and equip.

The report concludes that the US should make Mexico the first investment priority for police and justice reform. Honduras and the rest of Central America come second, and Haiti third. South American countries presumably come a distant fourth, suggesting a shift in US security priorities as they apply to the region.

share icon icon icon

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

What are your thoughts? Click here to send InSight Crime your comments.

We encourage readers to copy and distribute our work for non-commercial purposes, with attribution to InSight Crime in the byline and links to the original at both the top and bottom of the article. Check the Creative Commons website for more details of how to share our work, and please send us an email if you use an article.

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

Related Content

BRAZIL / 16 JUN 2021

Rio de Janeiro’s foremost militia leader has been gunned down by police, potentially shattering the belief that militias in the…

HOMICIDES / 29 AUG 2022

Police in Guanajuato, Mexico, are accused of being in the pocket of the Jalisco Cartel. But do they have a…

KIDNAPPING / 22 SEP 2021

The Venezuelan police have stepped in amid a spate of violent crimes caused by gang members pretending to sell cars…

About InSight Crime

THE ORGANIZATION

Escaping Barrio 18

27 JAN 2023

Last week, InSight Crime published an investigation charting the story of Desafío, a 28-year-old Barrio 18 gang member who is desperate to escape gang life. But there’s one problem: he’s…

THE ORGANIZATION

Europe Coverage Makes a Splash

20 JAN 2023

Last week, InSight Crime published an analysis of the role of Amsterdam’s Schiphol Airport as an arrival hub for cocaine and methamphetamine from Mexico.  The article was picked up by…

THE ORGANIZATION

World Looks to InSight Crime for Mexico Expertise

13 JAN 2023

Our coverage of the arrest of Chapitos’ co-founder Ovidio Guzmán López in Mexico has received worldwide attention.In the UK, outlets including The Independent and BBC…

THE ORGANIZATION

InSight Crime Shares Expertise with US State Department

16 DEC 2022

Last week, InSight Crime Co-founder Steven Dudley took part in the International Anti-Corruption Conference organized by the US State Department’s Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, & Labor and…

THE ORGANIZATION

Immediate Response to US-Mexico Marijuana Investigation

9 DEC 2022

InSight Crime’s investigation into how the legalization of marijuana in many US states has changed Mexico’s criminal dynamics made a splash this week appearing on the front page of…