HomeNewsBriefBrazil Authorities Simply Closed Thousands of Unsolved Murder Cases
BRIEF

Brazil Authorities Simply Closed Thousands of Unsolved Murder Cases

BRAZIL / 15 NOV 2016 BY LUIS FERNANDO ALONSO EN

A policy initiative in Brazil aimed at expediting justice in homicide cases resulted instead in the mass closure of investigations, illustrating how institutional shortcomings can frustrate even well-intentioned public policies.

The initiative was part of the 2011 National Strategy for Justice and Public Security (Estratégia Nacional de Justiça e Segurança Pública - ENASP), created by the National Justice Council (Conselho Nacional de Justiça - CNJ), National Council of the Public Ministry (Conselho Nacional do Ministério Público - CNMP), and the Justice Ministry. Its objective was to accelerate police investigations into homicide cases from before 2008 that remained open, O Globo reported.

When the program came into force, there were more than 138,000 open homicide investigations nationwide that fell within that time frame. As of November 8, 2016, more than 104,000 of those cases had been "concluded." However, 79 percent of the "concluded" investigations were simply closed, and only 19 percent were passed along to the judicial system. (See the data courtesy of Globo here in pdf format.)

The state of Rio de Janeiro, which had the highest number of unsolved murder investigations, also had the highest percentage of "concluded" cases that were simply closed, at 96 percent.

"This statistic is a scandal," said Fabio Uchôa, a judge in Rio de Janiero. "It reflects...the impunity that occurs in the country, especially in Rio de Janeiro."

These high levels of closed cases were not unique to the state of Rio de Janiero. In Paraíba, 87 percent of "concluded" investigations were simply closed. In Espírito Santo and Rondônia, the rate was 86 percent. Bahia and Sergipe closed 82 percent, while Rio Grande do Sul closed 80 percent and São Paulo and Santa Catarina closed 75 percent.

In just five states of the country, closed investigations accounted for less than half of the "concluded" cases: Amapá (45 percent), Piauí (44 percent), Acre (43 percent), Roraima (30 percent) and Pará (20 percent).

InSight Crime Analysis

Although the initiative was intended to encourage authorities to direct more resources to solving open murder cases, it appears to have instead pressured them in many instances to simply close the cases without further investigation. This may be partly due to a lack of the necessary investigative resources to handle the large number of murder cases, but other factors may also have played a role.

Reflecting on the disparities in closure rates, sociologist Julita Lemgruber of Cândido Mendes University said, "It's not just a matter of whether the police have more or fewer resources to investigate homicides. In states that clearly have fewer resources than Rio de Janeiro, the number of investigations passed on to the judicial system was much higher."

Lemgruber linked the high closure rates in major urban centers like Rio and São Paulo to the fact that most homicide victims in Brazil come from disadvantaged groups with relatively little political power. She suggested that authorities therefore had little incentive to seriously investigate the murders of victims who tend to be young, poor, dark-skinned people living in periferal areas.

    SEE ALSO: Brazil News and Profiles

Regardless of the reasons or causes, these statistics are concerning. The fact that so many murders went unsolved raises questions about the ability of authorities to thoroughly investigate other crimes such as extortion, kidnapping and money laundering.

share icon icon icon

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

What are your thoughts? Click here to send InSight Crime your comments.

We encourage readers to copy and distribute our work for non-commercial purposes, with attribution to InSight Crime in the byline and links to the original at both the top and bottom of the article. Check the Creative Commons website for more details of how to share our work, and please send us an email if you use an article.

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

Related Content

BRAZIL / 9 JUN 2021

Manaus, the economic heart of Brazil’s Amazon, has come under siege from the Red Command gang after the killing of…

CARIBBEAN / 7 JUN 2022

Several brutal killings have shaken the small Caribbean island nation of St. Lucia, as murders in the country reach record…

BRAZIL / 7 JUL 2021

Newly leaked audio recordings have sparked a political firestorm in Brazil - linking President Jair Bolsonaro to an extortion scheme…

About InSight Crime

THE ORGANIZATION

Escaping Barrio 18

27 JAN 2023

Last week, InSight Crime published an investigation charting the story of Desafío, a 28-year-old Barrio 18 gang member who is desperate to escape gang life. But there’s one problem: he’s…

THE ORGANIZATION

Europe Coverage Makes a Splash

20 JAN 2023

Last week, InSight Crime published an analysis of the role of Amsterdam’s Schiphol Airport as an arrival hub for cocaine and methamphetamine from Mexico.  The article was picked up by…

THE ORGANIZATION

World Looks to InSight Crime for Mexico Expertise

13 JAN 2023

Our coverage of the arrest of Chapitos’ co-founder Ovidio Guzmán López in Mexico has received worldwide attention.In the UK, outlets including The Independent and BBC…

THE ORGANIZATION

InSight Crime Shares Expertise with US State Department

16 DEC 2022

Last week, InSight Crime Co-founder Steven Dudley took part in the International Anti-Corruption Conference organized by the US State Department’s Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, & Labor and…

THE ORGANIZATION

Immediate Response to US-Mexico Marijuana Investigation

9 DEC 2022

InSight Crime’s investigation into how the legalization of marijuana in many US states has changed Mexico’s criminal dynamics made a splash this week appearing on the front page of…