HomeNewsAnalysisMexico's Unreliable Crime Data Calls Govt's Claims Into Question
ANALYSIS

Mexico's Unreliable Crime Data Calls Govt's Claims Into Question

MEXICO / 18 SEP 2015 BY PATRICK CORCORAN EN

A new report indicates that one of Mexico’s principal systems for collecting crime data is riddled with errors, raising questions about the reliability of the conclusions regarding the nation's recent drop in murders.

As reported by Animal Politico, during an 18-month period in 2013 and 2014, more than 70 percent of Mexico’s 32 states altered local crime data after it had already been submitted to the National Public Security System (the SNSP). 

In some cases, the changes in the data after its initial submission were enormous. Veracruz neglected to submit 299 murders committed inside the state during 2013, out of a total of 863 ultimately reported. It also retroactively added 360 cases of extortion, out of a total of just 461. 

In 2014 Michoacan erased nearly 3,000 crimes from its records after having already submitted them to the SNSP. This included nearly 400 cases of murder and manslaughter, and scores of extortion and kidnapping cases. The state’s explanation was that the crimes had been “reclassified,” but it has offered no additional details. Similar examples abound.

The changes were made without much fanfare -- there is a page within the SNSP site that lists modifications for each state -- and the reasons for them remain unclear.

The SNSP, which relies on the state governments to record the instances of a wide range of crimes, is one of the only resources for comprehensive and recent information on Mexican crime rates, and its data is widely used as a barometer of Mexican security. The fact that the data was so frequently and drastically mistaken suggests that any conclusions based on the SNSP should be taken with a grain of salt. 

Such errors and uncertainty over Mexican government data are unfortunately quite common, even beyond the time frame under consideration in the Animal Politico report. Diego Valle-Jones, a statistician who posts drug war analysis on his blog, has highlighted several inexplicable lapses in government crime reporting in recent years, whether in health records in the southern state of Chiapas or the more than 1,000 homicides missing from Chihuahua's records. 

InSight Crime Analysis

The mistakes don't appear to be anything more sinister than bureaucratic errors, but it does reflect a grave shortcoming for Mexican authorities. The fact that such dramatic mistakes could be made in the collection of basic crime stats, and that the alterations have been made without a full accounting of the source of the errors, calls into question the depth of the security gains made during the nearly three years of Enrique Peña Nieto’s presidency. 

From 2012 to 2014, the SNSP’s tally of murders nationally dropped from 21,736 to 15,653. This nearly 30 percent decline has become a foundation stone of Peña Nieto’s claims to have turned the page on the chaos of the Felipe Calderon era, but if the initial reporting errors are hiding much larger lapses that have not been corrected, the improvement may have actually been much milder. 

SEE ALSO: Mexico News and Profiles

The inability to reliably tabulate murders, where there is typically ample and indisputable evidence of a crime, raises even greater doubts about the statistics on crimes where uncertainty is built in, such as extortion and kidnapping. Such crimes, when successfully executed, leave no evidence of their existence for authorities, and both victim or perpetrator have a powerful incentive to not report them. That natural barrier to reliable reporting of kidnapping and extortion, coupled with the errors outlined above, suggests that the SNSP figures on both of these crimes are little better than worthless. 

The statistical errors are symbolic of a larger problem plaguing Mexico, in that they suggest the civil service is not fully competent at multiple levels of government. A reliable cohort of government employees at every level, from the agency heads to the low-level staffers responsible for implementing a given policy, are vital for any successful government strategy, including in security matters. Counting crimes is hardly the most complicated element of Mexico’s security problems, and a state that cannot be relied upon to arrive at a trustworthy sum is unlikely to be capable of the far more complicated tasks affecting security, such as building self-perpetuating mechanisms to root out corruption and tackle the anarchic state of the prison system

As a result, strategies that aim to create an idealized Mexico without addressing the basic competency issues at all levels of government are unlikely to succeed.  

share icon icon icon

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

What are your thoughts? Click here to send InSight Crime your comments.

We encourage readers to copy and distribute our work for non-commercial purposes, with attribution to InSight Crime in the byline and links to the original at both the top and bottom of the article. Check the Creative Commons website for more details of how to share our work, and please send us an email if you use an article.

Tags

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

Related Content

KNIGHTS TEMPLAR / 29 OCT 2014

The head of Mexican criminal group the Knights Templar, "La Tuta," has vowed to "fight to the end" in a defiant…

HUMAN RIGHTS / 28 JAN 2022

A number of media workers in Mexico have been shot and killed, stabbed to death and ambushed in armed attacks…

MEXICO / 25 APR 2022

The Mexican government's shuttering of a special criminal investigative unit that worked with US anti-drug agents has added new cracks…

About InSight Crime

THE ORGANIZATION

Who Are Memo Fantasma and Sergio Roberto de Carvalho?

24 JUN 2022

Inside the criminal career of Memo Fantasma  In March 2020, InSight Crime revealed the identity and whereabouts of Memo Fantasma, a paramilitary commander and drug trafficker living in…

THE ORGANIZATION

Environmental and Academic Praise

17 JUN 2022

InSight Crime’s six-part series on the plunder of the Peruvian Amazon continues to inform the debate on environmental security in the region. Our Environmental Crimes Project Manager, María Fernanda Ramírez,…

LA ORGANIZACIÓN

Series on Plunder of Peru’s Amazon Makes Headlines

10 JUN 2022

Since launching on June 2, InSight Crime’s six-part series on environmental crime in Peru’s Amazon has been well-received. Detailing the shocking impunity enjoyed by those plundering the rainforest, the investigation…

THE ORGANIZATION

Duarte’s Death Makes Waves

3 JUN 2022

The announcement of the death of Gentil Duarte, one of the top dissident commanders of the defunct Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC), continues to reverberate in Venezuela and Colombia.

THE ORGANIZATION

Cattle Trafficking Acclaim, Investigation into Peru’s Amazon 

27 MAY 2022

On May 18, InSight Crime launched its most recent investigation into cattle trafficking between Central America and Mexico. It showed precisely how beef, illicitly produced in Honduras, Guatemala…