HomeNewsAnalysisMore Drug War Aid for Central America, But With Security Taxes?
ANALYSIS

More Drug War Aid for Central America, But With Security Taxes?

CARSI / 24 JUN 2011 BY HANNAH STONE EN

There were plenty of vows of greater cooperation, as well as pledges for cash, at a Central American security conference in Guatemala, but perhaps more important were the signs of an emerging consensus on the need for higher taxes in the region.

Much discussion at the conference centered around international aid to the crime-afflicted isthmus. The countries of the region presented a new anti-crime strategy, adopted by the countries at a meeting in May, which is set to cost $953 million. It sets out plans for greater coordination between Central American nations, and the establishment of a regional commission to evaluate each country's progress on a set of targets, which include increasing drug interdiction, stopping gender violence, and improving education and training schemes.

The conference bore fruit, with almost two billion dollars promised to the region. One billion of this will come from the World Bank, while the Inter-American Development Bank will contribute $500 million. The U.S. pledged to raise aid to $300 million, some $200 million of which was already accounted for by commitments made by U.S. President Barack Obama on a recent visit to El Salvador.

Guatemala's government called the conference a "historic milestone." But perhaps more significant that the offers of aid, or the promises to work together, were the signs that various countries in the region are moving towards increasing tax revenues in order to fund their own fight against crime, and strengthen institutions.

U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton raised the subject of Central America's low tax burden, telling the conference that "True security cannot be funded on the backs of the poor," and that the rich, and businesses, should pay their fair share.

The politician's comments were a reference to the fact that Central America has one of the lowest tax burdens on earth. Tax revenues make up on average 13.8 percent of GDP in the region -- excluding Belize and Panama, for which the World Bank does not provide data. This makes it more difficult for governments to pay officials well enough to undercut corruption, and to have professional and well-equipped law enforcement and judicial systems.

Clinton's words echoed those of a former Costa Rican vice president, who recently told a U.S. Senate committee not to "let the Central American elites, who have never paid taxes, off the hook this time.”

This theme was backed by other voices at the conference. El Salvador's President Mauricio Funes said that tax increases across the region were "fundamental" for each country to be able to strengthen their own security systems. He pointed out that organized crime brings in revenues of $100 billion dollars in the region, and that governments need to be similarly well-funded in order to match this underworld.

At the conference, Guatemala's President Alvaro Colom stressed that drug "consumer" countries like the U.S. needed to do more for the fight against crime, considering its effects on the producer and transit countries. However, an official statement on the website of the Guatemalan presidency also pointed out that Guatemala was "no stranger" to the financial issues raised by Funes, and needed urgent tax reform.

Honduras has also recently been pushing forward with plans to levy a security tax on the wealthy and on big businesses. The proposed tax would raise around $79 million a year. If we consider that, for example, the much-discussed $300 million in U.S. aid would come to significantly less than this when divided between seven Central American nations, the idea of increasing domestic taxes begins to seem like an important accompaniment to international donations.

Moves by Central America's nations to raise taxes, and make security spending a public not a private matter, could mark a real shift in the region's crime policies. More than foreign aid, sustainable homegrown and self-funded initiatives could be the way to stop the region's slide into a disaster zone.

But a mayor stumbling block in the way of any plans to raise taxes in the region is the level of citizen distrust of governments. Any plans to spend more would have to be accompanied by efforts to make that spending more transparent and efficient, in order to convince the public that it is worthwhile.

share icon icon icon

What are your thoughts? Click here to send InSight Crime your comments.

We encourage readers to copy and distribute our work for non-commercial purposes, with attribution to InSight Crime in the byline and links to the original at both the top and bottom of the article. Check the Creative Commons website for more details of how to share our work, and please send us an email if you use an article.

Tags

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

Related Content

CARSI / 14 FEB 2012

The US State Department's proposed 2013 budget will reduce military and anti-drug aid to Latin America, including to the traditional…

CARSI / 7 NOV 2011

Guatemala and Nicaragua elected two former military commanders on November 6, whose vastly different political backgrounds belie their similarities on…

CARSI / 7 FEB 2012

Hardly any of Honduras' military budget for 2012 will be invested in military or police equipment, according to the Minister…

About InSight Crime

THE ORGANIZATION

Combating Environmental Crime in Colombia

15 JUN 2021

InSight Crime presented findings from an investigation into the main criminal activities fueling environmental destruction in Colombia.

THE ORGANIZATION

Collaborating on Citizen Security Initiatives

8 JUN 2021

Co-director Steven Dudley worked with Chemonics, a DC-based development firm, to analyze the organization’s citizen security programs in Mexico.

THE ORGANIZATION

InSight Crime Deepens Its Connections with Universities

31 MAY 2021

A partnership with the University for Peace will complement InSight Crime’s research methodology and expertise on Costa Rica.

THE ORGANIZATION

With Support from USAID, InSight Crime Will Investigate Organized Crime in Haiti

31 MAY 2021

The project will seek to map out Haiti's principal criminal economies, profile the specific groups and actors, and detail their links to elements of the state.

THE ORGANIZATION

We Have Updated Our Website

4 FEB 2021

Welcome to our new home page. We have revamped the site to create a better display and reader experience.