HomeNewsAnalysisLingering Question from Mexico Student Massacre: Why?
ANALYSIS

Lingering Question from Mexico Student Massacre: Why?

AYOTZINAPA / 20 NOV 2014 BY PATRICK CORCORAN EN

As Mexico struggles to come to terms with the mass murder of 43 students in Guerrero, among the many unanswered questions is why the group behind the killings did what what it did.

While many details remained to be fleshed out, the basic outline of the incident is essentially accepted: the 43 students were part of a larger group from a rural teachers’ school in Ayotzinapa heading to Iguala, Guerrero, to commandeer buses and raise funds for a future trip to a demonstration in Mexico City. Their stay in Iguala coincided with a major speech by the Iguala mayor’s wife, Maria de los Angeles Villa Pineda, who had political ambitions of her own and whose family is close to the Guerreros Unidos.

Desperate to avoid the interruption of her big political moment from the potentially rowdy student protesters, Villa Pineda and her husband, Jose Luis Abarca, set the municipal police and the Guerreros Unidos on the students. Over 50 people were killed in the melee, including 43 who were allegedly abducted, executed (or suffocated), and incinerated. (Some followers and media have not accepted this explanation.)

In response to the crime and the wave of anger it provoked, the federal government has sprung into action. Abarco and Villa Pineda went underground, and were found by federal authorities in Mexico City earlier this month. A steady stream of arrests of Guerreros Unidos members culminated in the October takedown of the group's maximum leader, Sidronio Casarrubias Salgado.

Among the range of reactions from the Mexican public, beneath the dismay and outrage and sadness, is the unanswered question of why. Why did a mid-level gang take such a provocative step, almost certain to generate the sort of massive media attention that precipitates a group’s collapse? Why did they equate a few dozen protesting teenagers, who were a regular feature in the Guerrero political and social landscape, with a threat worthy of mass execution?

The answers to these questions are important not only for shedding light on one of Mexico’s most notorious crimes in decades. They also speak to potential changes in the Mexican underworld, which could have repercussions elsewhere.

InSight Crime Analysis

It is clear that the Guerreros Unidos made an enormous miscalculation. The group has turned radioactive: its leaders are either in jail or a priority for federal officials, and its political allies that are not on the run or arrested are probably keeping their distance. The group’s total demise is a likely scenario in the near term. The leaders presumably never considered that murdering scores of students would put their livelihood at risk, but the recent developments make clear that they were mistaken.

The gang members also likely saw the students as rabble-rousers, economically disadvantaged and a public nuisance, and therefore not a group to inspire much sympathy. This view is not uncommon in Mexico. As a consequence, they presumably felt that there would be little public drive to investigate the disappearance of the mostly poor, rural teachers. But the executioners misread the popular response; it’s one thing to complain about shakedowns posing as fund-raising, it’s quite another to countenance a massacre in response.

Such a grave miscalculation also suggests an expectation of impunity from the Guerreros Unidos, even as they carried out one of the worst imaginable crimes. This theory is supported by the scores of bodies, discovered thanks to tips from arrested members of the group, which were buried in clandestine graves that evidently had nothing to do with the missing students. One suspects that there have been other killings, similar in method if smaller in scope to the Iguala murders, that have passed essentially unnoticed by the authorities. As the gang realized it could literally get away with murder, it kept pushing the envelope.

The same might be said for the former mayor. Another big part of the explanation likely lies in the details of the Guerreros Unidos’ relationship with Abarca and the mayor’s office. Reports that emerged subsequent to the massacre paint the mayor not only as a corrupt official looking the other way in exchange for kickbacks, but as a murderer and trafficker himself. The Guerreros Unidos appear to have operated as a sort of extralegal shock force at the orders of the mayor and his wife. This expanded the realm of mortal enemies far beyond what is typical for a drug trafficking group, to the point at which it included 43 aspiring teachers with no link to organized crime. And such a relationship not only encouraged delusions of invincibility; it also blurred the line between aggressiveness and foolhardiness.

The Guerreros Unidos’ intimate relationship with the mayor’s office in Iguala is not unusual in Mexico. There are many criminal groups that work with and depend on the local authorities. But it was aided by a series of uncommon circumstances, such as the mayor’s unique background and Iguala’s remoteness. And it seems unlikely to be repeated, making future massacres less likely. Unfortunately, the damage in Guerrero is already done.

share icon icon icon

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

What are your thoughts? Click here to send InSight Crime your comments.

We encourage readers to copy and distribute our work for non-commercial purposes, with attribution to InSight Crime in the byline and links to the original at both the top and bottom of the article. Check the Creative Commons website for more details of how to share our work, and please send us an email if you use an article.

Was this content helpful?

We want to sustain Latin America’s largest organized crime database, but in order to do so, we need resources.

DONATE

Related Content

HUMAN TRAFFICKING / 5 AUG 2022

Human trafficking appears on the rise in Mexico, with the government struggling to find a strategy forward.

CHAPITOS / 23 DEC 2022

The Chapitos are winning the internal war for the Sinaloa Cartel and doing it in a different way than their…

COCAINE / 15 MAR 2023

Australia and New Zealand are the most expensive cocaine markets in the world. For the Sinaloa Cartel, it's worth the…

About InSight Crime

THE ORGANIZATION

InSight Crime Contributes Expertise Across the Board 

22 SEP 2023

This week InSight Crime investigators Sara García and María Fernanda Ramírez led a discussion of the challenges posed by Colombian President Gustavo Petro’s “Total Peace” plan within urban contexts. The…

THE ORGANIZATION

InSight Crime Cited in New Colombia Drug Policy Plan

15 SEP 2023

InSight Crime’s work on emerging coca cultivation in Honduras, Guatemala, and Venezuela was cited in the Colombian government’s…

THE ORGANIZATION

InSight Crime Discusses Honduran Women's Prison Investigation

8 SEP 2023

Investigators Victoria Dittmar and María Fernanda Ramírez discussed InSight Crime’s recent investigation of a massacre in Honduras’ only women’s prison in a Twitter Spaces event on…

THE ORGANIZATION

Human Trafficking Investigation Published in Leading Mexican Newspaper

1 SEP 2023

Leading Mexican media outlet El Universal featured our most recent investigation, “The Geography of Human Trafficking on the US-Mexico Border,” on the front page of its August 30…

THE ORGANIZATION

InSight Crime's Coverage of Ecuador Leads International Debate

25 AUG 2023

This week, Jeremy McDermott, co-director of InSight Crime, was interviewed by La Sexta, a Spanish television channel, about the situation of extreme violence and insecurity in Ecuador…