The arrest in Guatemala of a United States-convicted drug trafficker illustrates that, when it comes to major players in the drug trade, the US justice system can be a paper tiger that ignores the worst atrocities.

Horst Walther Overdick, alias “El Tigre,” was arrested on November 5 in Cobán, the capital of Alta Verapaz, where he and his gang, the so-called “Tigers,” were allegedly trafficking drugs, according to Guatemala’s Attorney General’s Office. By November 7, four total members of the group had been arrested, Prensa Libre reported.

Overdick has served time for drug trafficking charges in the past. Prensa Libre reported he was captured in 2000 and 2002 in Guatemala. More famously, he was captured in April 2012, charged with drug trafficking by the Southern District of New York, and extradited to face those charges in December of that same year. 

SEE ALSO: Guatemala Border Attack Signals Lorenzana Clan’s Return

That arrest and extradition came just months after InSight Crime published an investigation into his connections with the Mexico-based criminal group, the Zetas. The Overdick-Zetas group had terrorized the country with a series of murders and massacres, including the mutilation of 27 farm workers, after which they had scrawled a menacing message against the owner on the white walls of his ranch. 

Overdick was not implicated directly in the massacre, but the incident sparked global headlines. Various Zetas were subsequently arrested or fled the country, and the group’s power dissipated. Overdick was arrested around the same time and then extradited. 

From Zetas Ally to Released Convict

The 2012 US indictment said Overdick had been trafficking drugs “from at least in or about 1999 up to and including in or about 2011.” It added a weapons charge. The two charges carried a maximum of life in prison and a mandatory minimum of 15 years, but Overdick was released in April 2019, after a little over six years.  

The reasons he was released are not clear. Overdick pleaded not guilty in the one court appearance that is on record in the case file, but most of the other court files are sealed. This is typical in cases where defendants cooperate and then receive what is known as a “downward departure,” i.e., a sentencing reduction. The prosecutor in the case, who has since retired from public service, did not respond to efforts to contact him. 

How Cooperation Deals Cut Drug Trafficking Sentences

The departures are commonplace for convicted traffickers, especially leaders that have a lot of information to offer. In fact, per the US Sentencing Commission, about 97% of all defendants in federal drug cases pleaded guilty in the years Overdick was in jail; of these, about a quarter received reduced sentences under what is known as 5K1.1, a provision that requires “substantial assistance to authorities.” Many more received sentence reductions by cooperating after they were sentenced, most of those under what is known as Rule 35(b), which allows for the ongoing evaluation of their cooperation in special hearings. 

Guatemala’s Extradited Traffickers Who Came Home

The list of beneficiaries from Guatemala includes Otoniel Turcios, who worked with Overdick and was twice convicted in the United States. He was captured in 1994 and eventually pleaded guilty in 1997 for trafficking drugs, for which he got time served. He then returned to Guatemala to resume his drug trafficking career, only to get caught again in 2010, this time in Belize. Belize expelled him to the US, then Turcios, who was well versed in the US system, simply flipped again, got released in 2015, and returned to Guatemala. 

SEE ALSO: Can Guatemala’s New Attorney General Reignite the Anti-Corruption Fight?

Then there is the case of Otto Herrera, another Guatemala-based trafficker who was arrested in 2007 in Colombia, extradited to the US in 2008, and released from US federal prison in 2013. There are also Marllory Chacón, a prolific money launderer whose sentence was reduced from 12 to 5 years, and Hayron Borrayo Lasmibat, a money launderer with ties to the Zetas captured in France who served four years of an eight-year sentence.  

El Mayo’s Life Sentence and His Family’s Deals

Other countries have seen similar cases. While the US Department of Justice (DOJ) announced the life sentence for the Sinaloa Cartel leader, Ismael Zambada García, alias “El Mayo,” in July, his brother and three sons were out of US custody, at least two of them after they made deals with the same DOJ, despite their own arrests and prosecutions. 

“It’s disgusting,” one former law enforcement agent, who spent most of his career working in Latin America, told InSight Crime about the steep sentence reductions. “And embarrassing.” 

Indeed, the former agent, who asked for anonymity because he continues to work with law enforcement, said that these types of cases are commonplace. While he was in Colombia, for instance, he saw numerous, large-scale traffickers return from the United States after relatively short sentences. 

“I saw many people get extradited twice,” the former agent added.

The US Justice Department did not respond to efforts for comment, but defenders of the system would point to the testimony of these and other traffickers, which helped secure high-profile convictions of drug traffickers such as Joaquín Guzmán Loera, alias “El Chapo.” 

El Mayo’s son, Vicente Zambada Niebla, alias “El Vicentillo,” and his brother, Jesús Zambada García, alias “El Rey,” both testified against El Chapo, who was convicted in 2019 and is serving a life sentence in a maximum-security federal prison in Colorado. In Guatemala, Chacón’s cooperation appears to have helped US authorities capture Borrayo. But although the information cooperators hand over builds more drug prosecutions in US courts, it rarely sheds light on the murders, massacres, and disappearances they left behind in Latin America, and the victims of those crimes have no say in the deals.

Colombia’s Paramilitaries: Drug Charges, No Murder Charges

Colombia, in fact, may be the hub of formerly extradited ex-convicts, some of whom, like Overdick, were connected to widespread atrocities. For example, in the late 2000s, the country extradited dozens of members of the United Self-Defense Forces (Autodefensas Unidas de Colombia – AUC), the proxy army and drug trafficking group that fought leftist guerrillas for decades and trafficked hundreds of tons of cocaine. 

Despite widespread massacres of civilians and other human rights abuses in Colombia, none of these AUC leaders faced murder charges. Instead, they faced drug trafficking charges, which most of them pleaded guilty to, and then cooperated. An InSight Crime analysis of 30 AUC cases in the US provided by a Berkeley-based project that tracked the cases showed the paramilitary leaders were sentenced, on average, to just over 12 years and served just under 9 of those years. A separate analysis done by the New York Times of an untold number of paramilitary leaders, published in 2017, said they had served an average of seven and a half years. 

SEE ALSO: Guatemala Profile

Among those who were released after relatively short sentences was Hernán Giraldo Serna, Giraldo’s nickname was “El Taladro,” or the Drill, because he had systematically raped so many women around his northern Colombia stronghold. He was released January 4, 2021, according to the US Bureau of Prisons, after being in US custody for just under 13 years. After he returned to Colombia, he was charged with abuse of minors. 

“The system didn’t dispense justice,” said Roxanna Altholz, a law professor at the University of California, Berkeley, who represented paramilitary victims as associate director of Berkeley Law’s clinic. 

Altholz–who directed the Berkeley project cited earlier–told InSight Crime that the case files were sealed and the prosecutors barred victims and victims’ advocates from accessing the paramilitary leaders to get information about the atrocities.  

“I never heard of a case where the victims received compensation nor truth,” she said. “Then when you look at the punishment, you see how lopsided the justice system is.”

Steven Dudley is the co-founder and co-director of InSight Crime and a senior research fellow at American University’s Center for Latin American and Latino Studies in Washington, DC. In 2020, Dudley...